POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS IN THE HEALTHCARE SECTOR OF UKRAINE DURING WARTIME: CHALLENGES, TRANSFORMATIONS AND INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCE
Abstract
In the current conditions of full-scale war, the healthcare system of Ukraine has acquired the status not only of a social but also of a strategic institution that determines the viability of the state and the resilience of society. Ensuring continuity of medical care, supporting both military personnel and civilians, and responding to mental health and humanitarian challenges shape its role as an integral component of national security. Despite the critical role of the healthcare system, its functioning is characterized by insufficient institutionalization of military medicine, financial instability, staff shortages, and unequal access to services in frontline and rear regions. The absence of a comprehensive strategic approach to political governance in healthcare reduces the effectiveness of responses to the multifaceted challenges of war and limits the potential for post-war recovery. In academic works, Karamushka L. focuses on the mental health of personnel, Kovalchuk V. analyzes legal aspects of the functioning of institutions during martial law, and Romashka S. examines financial mechanisms of healthcare support. Bondarenko-Zelinska N., Boryslavska M., Zelinskyi A. study the right to healthcare protection for vulnerable groups, Levi B., Davidovitch N., Dopelt K. analyze the impact of medical associations on policy, while Nitzan D., Mendlovic J., Ash N. investigate the management of the trauma system during wartime. The objective is to study the peculiarities of the development of political institutions in the field of healthcare in Ukraine under conditions of war, to analyze the experience of Israel and Georgia in combining medical and security policies, and to outline prospects for their adaptation to strengthen the resilience of the Ukrainian system. The article examines the transformations of the Ukrainian healthcare system under the influence of war: staff shortages, financial vulnerability, insufficient legal regulation of the status of military medical workers, and the lack of a comprehensive policy on mental health. Positive examples of decentralization and cooperation with civil society organizations are analyzed, as well as the international experience of Israel and Georgia, which demonstrate different models of institutional adaptation of healthcare systems in crisis conditions. The study proves that political institutions are a determining factor in ensuring the resilience of healthcare during war. Ukraine needs institutional consolidation of military medicine, the development of mechanisms for interagency coordination, guarantees of social protection for medical personnel, and financial stability. The use of international experience will make it possible to create a modernized system capable of functioning effectively both in times of crisis and in the post-war period.
Keywords: healthcare, war, political institutions, military medicine, national security, mental health.
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Аналіз Стратегії інтеграції ВПО та впровадження середньострокових рішень щодо внутрішнього переміщення на період до 2024 року, Право на захист, (2024, вересень, 22).
Вплив конфлікту на систему охорони здоров’я та акцентування уваги на конкретних потребах: тематичний звіт 22 вересня 2023 року, ACAPS, (2024, вересень, 22).
Карамушка, Л. (2022) Психічне здоров’я персоналу організацій в умовах війни: основні вияви та ресурси, Scientific notes of the University"KROK", 3(67), 124–33.
Ковальчук, В. (2023) Особливості правового регулювання функціонування органів місцевого самоврядування в період воєнного стану в Україні, Український часопис конституційного права, 4, 37–46.
Мороз, Н., Косик, В. (2022) Фінансова допомога Україні від міжнародних партнерів під час війни. Проблеми сучасних трансформацій. Серія: економіка та управління, 5, 28-29.
Sheliemina, N. (2023) The goals of sustainable development for Ukrainein the context of the deployment of health carereform, the analysis of medical efficiency and the role of the national health service in regulating processes in wartime, Actual Problems of Economics, 1(264), 77–93.
Bondarenko-Zelinska, N., Boryslavska, M., Zelinskyі, A. (2021) On the right to health protection of socially vulnerable groups of the population’, University Scientific Notes, 4 (82), 157–90.
Georgia post-conflict joint needs assessment wins a World Bank prize, World Bank, (2024, вересень 22).
Knowledge brief. health, nutrition and population global practice, World Bank, (2024, вересень, 22).
Levi, B., Davidovitch, N., Dopelt, K. (2021) In service of the society? Medical associations as agents of social change – implications for health policy and education in israel, Healthcare, 9 (10), 1264.
Spitka, T. (2023) National and International Civilian Protection Strategies in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, (2024, вересень, 22).
Jaffe, E. et. (2024) ‘Managing a mega mass casualty event by a civilian emergency medical services agency: lessons from the first day of the 2023 Hamas-Israel war’, International Journal of Public Health, (2024, вересень, 22).
References:
Analiz Stratehii intehratsii VPO ta vprovadzhennia serednostrokovykh rishen shchodo vnutrishnoho peremishchennia na period do 2024 roku [Analysis of the Strategy for the integration of IDPs and the implementation of medium-term solutions on internal displacement until 2024]. Pravo na zakhyst. Retrieved from https://archive.r2p.org.ua/strategiya-integracziyi-vpo-analiz/ (2024, September, 22). [in Ukrainian].
Vplyv konfliktu na systemu okhorony zdorovia ta aktsentuvannia uvahy na konkretnykh potrebakh [Impact of the conflict on the healthcare system and spotlight on specific needs]. ACAPS. Retrieved from https://www.acaps.org/fileadmin/Data_Product/Additional_resources/20231004_ACAPS_thematic_report_Ukraine_impact_of_the_conflict_on_healthcare_system_and_spotlight_on_specific_needs_Ukrainian.pdf. (2024, September, 22). [in Ukrainian].
Karamushka, L. (2022) Psykhichne zdorovia personalu orhanizatsii v umovakh viiny: osnovni vyiavy ta resursy [Mental health of organizational staff in wartime: main manifestations and resources], Scientific Notes of the University “KROK”, 3(67), 124–33. [in Ukrainian].
Kovalchuk, V. (2023) Osoblyvosti pravovoho rehuliuvannia funktsionuvannia orhaniv mistsevoho samovriaduvannia v period voiennoho stanu v Ukraini [Features of legal regulation of the functioning of local self-government bodies during martial law in Ukraine], Ukrainskyi chasopys konstytutsiinoho prava, 4, 37–46. [in Ukrainian].
Moroz, N., Kosyk, V. (2022) Finansova dopomoha Ukraini vid mizhnarodnykh partneriv pid chas viiny [Financial assistance to Ukraine from international partners during the war]. Problemy suchasnykh transformatsii. Seriia: ekonomika ta upravlinnia, 5, 28-29. [in Ukrainian].
Sheliemina, N. (2023) The goals of sustainable development for Ukraine in the context of the deployment of healthcare reform, the analysis of medical efficiency and the role of the national health service in regulating processes in wartime. Actual Problems of Economics, 1 (264), 77–93. [in English].
Bondarenko-Zelinska, N., Boryslavska, M. and Zelinskyi, A. (2021) On the right to health protection of socially vulnerable groups of the population, University Scientific Notes, 4 (82), 157–190. [in English].
Georgia post-conflict joint needs assessment wins a World Bank prize. World Bank. Retrieved from https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2010/03/31/georgia-post-conflict-joint-needs-assessment-wins-a-world-bank-prize. (2024, September, 22). [in English].
Knowledge brief. Health, nutrition and population global practice. World Bank Retrieved from https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099802505242216398/pdf/IDU07bfac40d035c20431a0bc1b0755ced4057df.pdf. (2024, September, 22). [in English].
Levi, B., Davidovitch, N. and Dopelt, K. (2021) In service of the society? Medical associations as agents of social change – implications for health policy and education in Israel, Healthcare, 9(10), 1264. [in English].
Spitka, T. (2023) National and International Civilian Protection Strategies in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-20390-9_2. (2024, September, 22). [in English].
Jaffe, E., et al. (2024) Managing a mega mass casualty event by a civilian emergency medical services agency: Lessons from the first day of the 2023 Hamas-Israel war, International Journal of Public Health, Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.3389/ijph.2024.1606907. (2024, September, 22). [in English].
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26886/2414-634X.3(63)2024.4
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.